There have been many lessons I have learned as a parent, and one of the most valuable lessons that fortunately I learned early on-- is that punishment does not work. Does not work, I repeat this, because we are so marinated in this construct that we can hardly remove it from our lives. But seriously, it does not work, and not only does it not work, what it does is destroy trust and relationship. If we believe, really believe that we will be punished for doing certain things, it only tells us that what we are doing is wrong, it does not open up possibilities for what is right.
Punishment makes people feel so unsafe, it boxes them into a corner, where their creativity which is needed to see possibilities is shut down. I found a wonderful explanation of this, this morning, reading through a clinical book called Trancework by Michael Yapko, this is how he puts it; “In simply punishing someone for doing something wrong, there is nothing provided to tell the person what the right thing is to do. The person merely learns what not to do; receiving repeated punishment with no alternatives provided leads to frustration, anger, and finally a point where punishment is no longer effective” (p. 286).
For me, it was as simple as spanking my child and realizing that they would do the same thing that I spanked them for over again, so I could spank them again and again and again and they would still do the same thing. As explained above, the spanking produced no change in the behavior, but what did change, was the relationship. I felt horrible, my child felt betrayed and then I somehow had to repair all that on top of finding alternatives to the behavior which started the whole thing. What I also had to do, was examine why it felt so awful to even want to punish someone. What thoughts, beliefs, did I actually hold about people, to imagine they needed to be punished, and that I was the one to do it?
Finally, reading this, and put so succinctly, validates how I came to view how people grow and change, how people create loving relationships. In safety, with encouragement, with alternatives, not punishment. Although I don’t consider myself a Christian, there are still Bible verses that bounce around in my head, and this one comes to mind, perfect love casts out all fear.
There is no fear where love exists. Rather, perfect love banishes fear, for fear involves punishment, and the person who lives in fear has not been perfected in love. 1 John 4:18.
As I raised my daughters, I read the Bible regularly, I held onto the verses that made sense to me, that made me feel like I could trust myself, especially as a parent. There were some verses that when I internalized them, and acted on them; made my life and my relationships better. This I believe is wisdom, finding and accepting words that most affirm our best selves, the selves we strive to be, that create the relationships we want to have, that build the places of safety and growth in our lives. So, whether it is a clinical book, or a book a wisdom, words help to affirm and to guide us to articulate and share where we are most loved and most human.